WEDM Trouble Shooting EDM Wire Breakage and other WEDM operational issues

WEDM Operational Problems & Solutions

The document below is a complementary resource provided by GIP Experts, and provides advice on trouble shooting a wide range of EDM operational issues and is based on a post on EDMParts website . It is a “trouble shoot guide” , an a helpful resource to the wire EDM operators we trust. If you would like to receive a complementary chart in excel or PDF version please contact us by e-mail & let us know.

May your sparks always be ON-Time!

Wire EDM: Reasons for EDM Wire Breakage

Wire EDM: Reasons for EDM Wire Breakage

[Full article by EDM Club – Edited by GIP June 9, 2021]

Much research has been done on the issue of wire breakage during the EDM machining process. But before we explore the types of wire that can be used to decrease wire breakage in certain materials, we must first look at what causes wire breakage in general.

Current Density

There are several key factors involved when determining what caused the wire breakage. The first and sometimes the obvious is the current density: the amount of current on any given surface area. When that exceeds the physical limitations of electrical current flowing on the surface of the wire, it creates enough heat to melt the wire.

For example, a 2″-thick piece of tool steel as a contact area along the wire of 2″—this is the surface area that will conduct the cutting current to the workpiece. The lesser thickness of a .5″ workpiece would have much less contact area. This should not be confused with peak current, which is the available amperage or power on the wire. Peak current can be compared to pressure and current density can be compared to volume; both can be controlled by our choice of condition settings or (E-code selection).

One of the easiest ways to control the current density is to decrease the frequency of the spark by increasing the Off-time between sparks. This is accomplished by adjusting the off-time setting of the spark in the E-code, by manually setting the Off-time in the control higher, so the power supply will automatically decrease the sparks On-Time. But this will slow down your cutting speed.

Dielectric Flushing – DI-Water 

Another cause of wire breakage can be the flushing of the wire. This is the first thing we usually reach to adjust and the easiest to see immediate results. Bad flushing can come from poor head placement, usually too far away from the workpiece. If moving the head closer is not an option because of clamps or other obstructions, then increasing the volume of water could resolve the situation.

Sometimes you will notice air in the cutting area due to cavitation from high water pressure; this is most common when starting a cut from an outside edge of your part. Usually, the condition will only last until the wire has cut far enough into the part to create a wire slot into which the water can flow, and cool and clean the cutting area. Lowering On-time, feed rate and rising Off-time will eliminate the wire breakage here.

Power Application

The point at which power is applied to the wire is a point of wire break that is sometimes overlooked. You will notice that the wire will break at a point near the top surface of the part. This is caused by worn or misadjusted power contacts. By replacing or adjusting the contact plate, the breakage will stop immediately.   

Poor Maintenance

Poor maintenance is not as common of a cause but can be just as important to consider and one of the more difficult to pinpoint. This will usually be in the wire transport system and can be dirty wire rollers, worn guides, small bits of broken EDM wire, misadjusted wire tension or bad water conductivity. A check of the wire path from roller to scrap bin is best done by a careful inspection of every component in order. This may take more time to do during a job than if an inspection was done just prior to starting the cut. Check the Conductivity Level of the Dielectric & hours on the DI resin, and if there is any question about the life left, replace the bottle or resin charge. It will not hurt to make a resin change early when in doubt. Beyond these common causes of wire breakage, power supply board failure or grossly selected cutting settings would be less likely, but just as important to have on the checklist as you look for the cause and cure.

More to come in the next blog about how different wire types will aid in decreasing wire breakage and increasing speed.


WHAT MAKES WEDM FUN FOR YOU? 

The Great artwork that is produced on the machines is one for me!

   Let’s start at the beginning, all of us have a story and this is a little of mine. When I was an apprentice, I was selected to learn to run the NEW LeBlond Makino EC 3025. It was the 1st wire EDM in our shop. What really got me excited about machine was a 4-axis sample part, it was the one and a two on the backside. John Aldridge was the service technician who was training me it was a great experience for a young apprentice in 1990.

It was John’s program to demo the capability. John is still with Makino today and we even worked together for a short time. Doing intricate parts on a wire machine is very satisfying and I have seen many art pieces the talented tool makers and operators have created. In this post I am going to share some pictures of what I have made and some I have found during my WEDM Journey! I hope you enjoy what you see!

Send WEDM Tech Wize your Favorite Art works! An we will add to the Collection!  george@gipintl.com

Pagoda cut on a Makino EDM U53K

Pagoda cut on a Makino EDM U53K

NOT a WEDM – But could be and it is so COOL!

Remember send WEDM Tech Wize your Favorite WEDM Art works! An we will add to the Collection!  george@gipintl.com

Best Wire EDM Machine (WEDM) for each EDM Application

Starting off the NEW Year 2021 with a difficult but fun subject to debate. The subject of what is the BEST WEDM in the industry it is a bit subjective to the person who is using the machines. So please understand this is my prospective and my 30 years of being in the industry studying the art of WEDM. I will start with my bottom and work my way up to the number one choice. So, what do you think of when you are thinking bottom brands?

#11 BROTHER WEDM

Very Basic 2 Axis & 4 Axis work – Great for a Garage Shop or starter WEDM! Service is hard to find these days in USA.

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

#9. Accutex & #10. Exectek

I have been unimpressed with the older models, they are lower priced option of course. They seem to be copies of the other brands and I would not pick them for high accuracy work. They do seem to be improving the systems and I have very limited knowledge/experience so take this with a grain of salt. General shop work – lower accuracy jobs.

#8. ONA

This Spanish brand has had very limited exposure to the USA market. They just never caught on from what I saw. Their niche was LARGE work machines (Also some aerospace). Plus, very hard to get service because you could not keep track of who was the distributor of the brand in USA. Per LinkedIn they are the oldest EDM machine manufacturer in the world!

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

#7. Mitsubishi

This is a tough one for ALL the Mits users (sorry) the reason is the older non-Linear machines. I think they are much better now then the ball screw era machines. Why – well it comes from the knowledge of service techs needing to do a ball bar test and set/tweak parameters to get the WEDM to cut a round dowel holes. This was done on new machines on every set-up. Just not impressed with the rigidity of the old machines. New Linear machines seem much more rigid and a better design, matching the e-pack technology that was always good and seemed to make the machines so popular! The Linear motors have in fact made the construction more ridge than the old ball screw models per an industry expert – it is correcting the construction errors in the machines design!

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

#6. Fanuc

This WEDM is Very popular, and I have no negative notes on the machine. The users like the machine and they run it seems much longer than you would expect. Great for progress dies & general WEDM jobs. Service is also really good as I never hear customers complain about getting help. 

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

#5. Sodick

Sodick machines are equipped with in-house developed NC controls, linear motors, and motion controllers. They have produced with their proprietary linear motor drive systems 45,000 units shipped worldwide. The industry’s only 10-year positioning accuracy guarantee has now proven itself for 20 full years since its inception. Sodick changed the industry of machine tools world-wide with the Linear motion. Their cutting conditions are the weak point in the past. Technology in the machines is good they just need more of it.

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize


https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

#4 Seibu

Seibu is a name that not all in USA know. Seibu high precision wire EDMs are 100% made in Japan. They are the only EDM manufacturer who guarantees a pitch accuracy down to +/- 1 micron. Although new to the U.S. market, Seibu has a long history. They created the world's first CNC wire EDM in 1972. Their wire EDMs are built in Seibu's ISO certified factory in Koga City, Fukuoka Prefecture which is located in southern Japan. Seibu machines target the high-end precision wire EDM market which requires a quality machine designed to last and produce consistent results for 25+ years.

Only 50 machines are individually handcrafted per month. Seibu’s manufacturing philosophy is about quality and not quantity. All machine castings are hand scraped, which uses a blade to remove high spots left behind during the machining process resulting in improved part geometry, repeatability, and surface finish. Guideways are checked for flatness, lasered for straightness, and test cuts are performed on all machines which are checked on a CMM for accuracy. Since Seibu wire EDMs are manufactured in Japan, they are built for precision and will outlast and outperform the competition. (This came from the Seibu website)

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

#3 Makino

In the machining world Makino is a world leader in technology & WEDM is no exception -  getting their start working with Agie due to a flood at their Switzerland factory.

They have grown from a niche machine to a powerful player in the industry. Their WEDM machines are built just like their milling machines. (solid as a Rock) Makino is the world leader in both Sinker & Wire EDM. With more than 140 patents, a Makino EDM means faster processing times and superior surface finishes for even the most complex part geometries. Makino turns innovation and technology into increased production and a lower cost per part for there customers.

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

#2 Charmilles

Charmilles started in the EDM business in 1952 in Switzerland, debuting the first machine in 1955 in Milan Italy. In the 1980’s & 1990’s they innovated the WEDM industry with CNC controls. Their controls were simpler to understand, but still powerful. They made many models during those two decades. They had a HIGH accuracy model and a HIGH Taper model – Both great machines in their respective applications. True leaders of the industry! Merging with Agie at the end 2006 – Lead for 22 years in the USA by Harry Moser. 

Always ahead of the curve and looking for the next big improvement! Service and Parts were top notch as well. 

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

#1 Agie

Agie is the world leader for many years the Benchmark of all OEM’s.

What can be said about Agie machines? They are the most accurate WEDM in the marketplace and everyone was chasing them for many years! Were they the perfect machine? Not in my opinion the control was the most difficult to understand and the number of pages that were used to run the machine, was far more than any of the others. The results though were as perfect as it could get!

I never run an Agie so my experience is from talking with others who did. Some of the innovations – 1. 1979 Automatic Wire Threading 2. 1987 CONTROL SYSTEM FOR OPTIMIZING AND MONITORING THE EDM PROCESS 3. 1993 AGIE FUZZYTRON HSS + HSF GENERATORS 4. 1996 AGIECUT EVOLUTION AND AGIEVISION  5. 2001 AGIECUT VERTEX 6. AGIECUT PROGRESS, AGIETRON HYPERSPARK just name a few.

Currently now joined together as one company Agie & Charmilles manufacturer 4 grades of WEDM”S  1. Micro Machining 2. High Speed Machining 3. Top End Accuracy 4. General Purpose – An Adding a NEW machine in 2020 the CUT AM 500 for cutting off additive manufactured parts. The WEDM is a Horizontal cutting machine that uses distilled water with additives to increase conductivity. While the conductivity of dielectric for a standard wire EDM application is typically between 20 and 5 micro siemens per centimeter, the conductivity of the CUT AM 500’s dielectric is almost 2,000 micro siemens per centimeter. AgieCharmilles is always looking to the future and so should we all! 

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

All the brands have a place in the market, or they would not be made!

There are many pros & cons to look at when evaluating the brands. 

What is important to you is the applications you are tackling. So, focus on the

goals you have and the work you are doing. The best machine for that application is 

sure, to be found in the price range you can afford.

 I did a little survey to see what user’s Think and here are the results!

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

I hope the above information is helpful to you and is taken as one person’s opinion – I am sure everyone has their perspective, and it is okay to like something different than I do. Just like the Chevy, Ford, & Dodge debate it is up to you! An what works for some does not work for others!

Let’s do something fun next time and look at WEDM art on the NEXT edition of WEDM Tech WIZE.   “May your Sparks always be ON-TIME!”+

Calculating EDM Wire Costs with WEDM Tech Wize

Calculating EDM Wire Costs

Scrapped Time or Parts Up in Smoke .png

 How to Calculate EDM Wire Costs

WEDM costs can vary depending on many factors, one main factor is the wire you are using as your electrode! Plain Brass wire is the most popular and you would like to think the price would not change by much between vendors. This is of course not the case because the market of users is always looking for a better deal! So, can you find a cheaper EDM wire? SURE! Will it work maybe?

Frankly, I don’t think buying the off brands for pennies less a pound is a good idea if you want to run 24/7 and have no issues. The buyer beware of where the wire is being made and if it is guaranteed should be a priority. It is not just the wire cost that might get scrapped, but the Tool Steel and time already put into the part or parts that are set-up in the machine that could be scrapped! Then the WEDM machines run time that could be wasted at $175.00 - $250.00 dollars an hour that adds up Fast!   

How to Figure out Cost of Using Brass or Coated EDM Wire

To figure the cost of using brass or any coated wire e.g. Plasma by GIP, you need to know your initial cost. 

  Let's start with the brass price per pound at $5.25. Then the diameter size since .010” is the standard we will go with that. Next thing you need to know is how many yards are in a pound of wire? That would be 1,193 yards per pound  for .010” wire. ( Side Note: Which would equal 13,123 yards on a 11 Lb. spool.) Since the WEDM is spooling off wire in yards per minute (or Meters per minute) we need to look at the E-Code for that amount.  

  Doing some quick math - if 1,193 yards equals 1 pound of wire, at $5.25 a pound the cost per yard would be $0.0044 cents per yard. With this number you can  calculate the wire cost per job once you know the amount of minutes the cut time will be. That is of course just one of the costs that need to be add to the job quote, but it is an important one to make sure you can make a profit on the job.  

The question is when is coated wire the better choice to make money? 

Well, if you need to get more parts done faster then coated wire can help you! See example:

Calculating EDM Wire Cost examples.png

Figuring a 30% faster cut time the difference is $0.80 cents per minute higher cost, but you also need 

to figure you now have 12 more minutes of time to make more parts. If you made 36 parts in 24 hours,

Now you could make those 36 parts in 16.8 Hours so you could now make 15 more parts in the same period. 

So, in 7.2 hours, how much more money can you generate in the extra time? It will all depend on the job!  

Get a Free EDM Wire Cost Calculator

If you would like to get a copy of the full excel spread sheet, fill out the request form below with your contact information and we will send it to you by e-mail.

This is all a part of the service from GIP as we plan to build the best EDM Supply company with todays GIP High Performance EDM Wire made by BEDRA & ThermoCompact as the cornerstone. 

Let us know how we can help you and what you would like to see in the future editions of 

WEDM Tech WIZARD.  

“May your Sparks always be ON-TIME!”

WEDM Technical Advice & Articles - The Metallurgy of Brass EDM Wire

The Metallurgy of Brass EDM Wire – Part #3  Continued from “The Role of Metallurgy in EDM Wire”


  Continuing with our exploration of Metallurgy of EDM wire & work pieces from part 2, we move on to the bedrock of Wire EDM!

We know brass works well as an EDM wire material because it is a stable conductor. Today brass represents the most popular wire type by a very wide margin. Undoubtedly the reason people first tried brass is because it is stronger than copper and they assumed it would resist wire breakage. Although it is indisputable that brass is stronger than copper, it turns out that has little to do with the real reason it works better in WEDM. In order to understand the true value of brass in this application, we need to spend a few minutes understanding some of the basic metallurgy of brass.

Brass is an alloy of copper and zinc. If one takes a block of zinc and presses it against a block of copper while heating the two, one will form brass as the copper atoms diffuse into the zinc and the zinc into the copper. However metallurgy tells us there are many different forms, or in its language different phases of brass, and each phase can be uniquely defined by its chemical, physical, and mechanical properties. In the picture below we see that in a diffusion couple formed between copper and zinc, we have developed three distinctly different phases of brass -- alpha phase, beta phase, and gamma phase. There has also been a new development Epsilon Phase it is more of a coating than a true phase though.

    Below, I have listed some of the distinguishing characteristics of these brass phases as they relate to EDM. Common EDM brass wire is alpha phase brass with a zinc content of 35% to 37% zinc. The choice of this alloy composition is no accident. The zinc content of 35% to 37% is as high as one can safely achieve in a commercial Brass alloy and still have the alloy remain alpha phase brass. What is so important about alpha phase brass? Alpha phase brass is very ductile and can very easily be drawn to fine diameter wire at room temperature. Higher zinc content phases of brass become increasingly brittle which either prevents them form being cold drawn altogether, or significantly raises the cost to produce them.

Beta phase brass has a higher zinc content than alpha phase brass 45% versus 35% to 37% zinc and has only a slightly lower melting point than alpha phase. Although it will work harden faster and become more brittle and therefore more difficult to draw cold than alpha phase, one can play a metallurgical trick on it. Used as a relatively thin coating on a copper or alpha phase brass core, it can be successfully cold drawn. The trick is to have the thin coating metallurgically bonded to the core so it can be forced to deform and therefore cold drawn into fine wire. Hence its use as the coating of “X-Type” and “D-Type” wires.

   Unfortunately, gamma phase brass is less ductile and completely brittle because of the complex crystal structures that are formed, but its very high zinc content and relatively high melting point make it extremely attractive as a candidate coating material. There are metallurgical tricks that can also be played on it to bond the discontinuous particles of gamma phase to the core wire, and so it has become the basis of the recently introduced “Gamma-Type” wires. We will talk more on Gamma & Epsilon in the future.

    https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize Brass Metallurgy Review

    https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize Brass Metallurgy Review

  Getting back to brass EDM wire, the tensile strength of brass wires range from 54,000-173,000 PSI, (373 N/mm² - 1200 N/mm²) depending upon the composition of the alloy and how its tempered.

Brass wires are polished gold in color.

Brass wires with a matte finish or with discoloration are indications of oxidation or contamination.

Brass wire is an all-around value product that can be used by almost all machines.

Brass wire is cost-effective cutting of tool steels & most materials is possible with plain brass wire.

Available in elongation ranges from <2% to over 30%, wires with low percentages of elongation will thread reliably but are limited in tapering ability. Half-Hard & Soft wires with high elongation can taper-cut to 45° in some WEDM’s but with much reduced threading reliability if you don’t have an annealing unit on your WEDM! 

What is the difference between Half Hard & Soft brass wire you might ask? 

Well the tensile strength is less in soft wire. 

  1. Half-Hard wire range is start at 500 N/mm²

  2. Soft wire range start at 440 N/mm² and go down

The last thing I will touch on is the negative of brass wire!

Copper is the best conductor of electricity.

So brass being 65% to 63% copper should be pretty good too right?

Not really if you look at copper at 100% conductive, brass with 35% to 37% zinc in it is only 25% to 28% as conductive as copper!

What does that mean to operators? Basically It will cut slower than a copper core wire will.

That is not the only negative in my experience brass wire is not suited well for two materials carbide 

& PCD.

Why is that? Because it will actual start electro plating the material in the skim passes.

The materials after finishing will have a gold color and the surface stays that way after cleaning and it 

is soft. Not what you want in a cutting tool edge. So you don’t want to use brass wire in those applications.

 Then what wire do you want to use for Carbide & PCD? We will address this in the future! 

The Next edition of WEDM Tech Wize we will look at why EDM Wire Breaks! 

“May your Sparks always be ON-TIME!”

 

The Physical Properties of Eroded Surfaces Encountered In Wire EDM - Part #2

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

The Physical Properties of Eroded Surfaces Encountered In Wire EDM – Part #2  Continued from “The Role of Metallurgy in EDM Wire”

 It might be easiest to start this discussion by considering what are the potential physical surface properties which have been suggested to control the wire flushing efficiency in WEDM.  Flushing in the WEDM application involves removing the solid debris created by each individual discharge which in fact is created one at a time in rapid succession but never two simultaneously.  The discharge envelope collapses under the pressure of the liquid dielectric medium (D.I. Water in most cases) after the ON-time and OFF-time cycles are completed by quenching the debris converting it to solid particulate.  

Those candidate surface properties controlling the wire’s contribution to flushing are:

1. “Vaporization Temperature” (represented by eroded surfaces’ Boiling Point) as suggested by the traditionally accepted theories of  WEDM  Heat of Sublimation as characterized by the energy per unit volume needed to transform the material affected by each individual discharge. If you will recall the Post of “Five Myths of EDM” the first candidate property cannot be the surfaces’ “vaporization temperature” because, as discussed in that Post, there is no such animal since metals vaporize over a very wide range of temperatures and not at some arbitrary fixed temperature

So that leaves 

2. the Heat of Sublimation as the only viable candidate. You need to know, as illustrated in the previous Post, that sublimation is defined as the process whereby a substance transitions directly from the solid to the gas state, without passing through the liquid state.  The Heat of Sublimation is the heat required to accomplish that transition and has the correct units, e.g. KJ/cm3, which relate to the WEDM process where one is trying to remove unit volumes of the workpiece.  

This Skim pass shows an example of the Discharge during the WEDM process: This is easy Flushing! www.gip-edmwire.com

This Skim pass shows an example of the Discharge during the WEDM process: This is easy Flushing! www.gip-edmwire.com

  Each discharge introduces a finite amount of energy into finite units of volume at both ends of the discharge envelope, i.e. at the wire and the workpiece. So, what is the relationship of Heat of Sublimation to flushing efficiency?  We just said that each discharge introduces a finite amount of energy into the discharge envelope in the gap between the wire electrode and the workpiece, some fixed portion of that energy will be delivered to the wire and the balance to the workpiece.  We will have the most efficient flushing of the wire debris if the maximum proportion of wire debris is from solidified vapor, i.e. smaller sized particulate.  That maximum will be determined by the Heat of Sublimation of the eroded wire volume, i.e. the lower the energy required to accomplish the transition the higher the probability it will happen.  The same is true of the workpiece but unfortunately one has little control over that since the workpiece is a given and not a choice.  As we will see later, that does not mean this parameter cannot be used to understand the performance of the workpiece. However, we do have control over the physical properties of the wire surface as determined by one’s choice of wire type.

   The following chart lists the volumetric heats of sublimation of the metallic elements.

Volumetric Value Chart for Metallic Elements www.gip-edmwire.com

Volumetric Value Chart for Metallic Elements www.gip-edmwire.com

Unfortunately, the volumetric heats of sublimation of metallic alloys are not readily available but one can assume they logically would be similarly ranked in the same order and magnitudes as those of the predominate alloying element of a given alloy system, e.g. iron in the case of tool steels or zinc in the case of brass alloys.  We will have more to say about the metallurgy of the brass alloy system which is critical to the WEDM application in a subsequent Post, but for now just consider the ranking of the metallic elements.  We are not so interested in the absolute values of the heats of sublimation but rather to their relative magnitudes.  For example, the relatively low value of zinc explains its predominant role in the WEDM application.  Although we have and will be focusing on the implications of this chart to the wire debris contributing to the total debris being flushed, note that the chart can also be used to better understand the simplicity or difficulty of using WEDM to erode various workpiece materials.  Note that aluminum has about half the value of iron (Tool Steel).  Do you suppose that has anything to do with the faster cutting speed of eroding aluminum parts as compared to tool steel parts?  The problem is aluminum flushes so efficiently it also obstructs the filtration system with its very fine debris particulate.  Guess why that might be!  Now that you understand the heart of our concept of approaching wire type selection, we will move on to the metallurgy of brass wire in the next edition of WEDM Tech Wize. “May your Sparks always be ON-TIME!”

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize



The Role of Metallurgy In EDM Wire - The Technology of Flushing

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

The Role of Metallurgy in EDM Wire

The metallurgical properties of the wire and the workpiece are equally important to the mechanics of flushing in EDM, and as most of you are aware, EDM needs great flushing.

Thus the role of metallurgy in EDM is quite extensive. Not only do the physical properties of surfaces influence flushing by determining the particulate size of the eroded debris, but the electrical properties of the wire and workpiece control the energy transfer process at the gap.

The fracture mechanic properties of the wire, control its breakage frequency which in turn controls the electrical circuit integrity.

As everyone here knows, when the wire electrode breaks in WEDM, no current flows, and no metal can be removed as the only thing that vaporizes is profits.

Disipline Influence.png
Which type of wire cuts better? Keep reading it will be worth the time!

Which type of wire cuts better?

Keep reading it will be worth the time!

Critical EDM Wire Properties

•Zinc Concentration/Melting Point of Eroding Surface

•Fracture Resistance (a.k.a. Fracture Toughness) 

•Electrical Conductivity 

•Handling Characteristics, Particularly For AWT

We can now focus on the critical wire properties in WEDM, from the metallurgical perspective. We will be looking at zinc concentration and melting point of the eroding surface, fracture resistance, electrical conductivity, and handling characteristics.

The handling characteristics, more specifically the wire straightness, is critically important to those machine without annealing units as part of there automatic wire threaders, so older machines! As you might suspect, this property is also related to metallurgical phenomenon, but this really in the domain of wire manufacturers, so we will not be digging into it here.

The Annealing unit have made this much less an issue as they have solved the problem of the wire not threading EVERYTIME!

The Technology of Flushing

 If you take nothing more than this away from my article, you will be well on your way to understanding the metallurgy of EDM wires.

Earlier I said there is no such thing as a vaporization temperature for metals. However vaporization as a process is critically important to EDM, and the property that controls it is known as the heat of sublimation. Do not be intimidated by this complicated sounding name; it is quite simple concept which we will consider momentarily. In the meantime the fact is, the heat of sublimation determines the flush-ability of wire and workpiece.

Low values yield good flush-ability; high values yield poor flush-ability. Zinc and zinc alloys have low values and therefore provide good flush-ability.

The following two sentences tell you much of what you need to know about wire selection.  

When considering EDM wires, the one with surface with the highest zinc content will cut the fastest, IF, that surface with the high zinc content is thick and tenacious enough to survive the erosion process.

The tenacity of the surface is directly proportional to its melting point with a minimum 550oC required for superior performance. 

Notice I capitalized the “if” because it is a very “big” if. Thick and tenacious are relative terms that can only be fully judged after the fact. Thickness is important because there must be enough of the eroding surface available to make it through the gap.

Tenacity is important because the large values of the physical and hydraulic forces that exist in the gap of wire EDM are capable of deforming and/or removing some of the surface. It is literally possible for the surface to be “blown away.

Hopefully not like this!

Hopefully not like this!

The Melting Point

Hence the importance of melting point. Higher melting points prevent the surface from being softened and distorted by the large hydraulic and mechanical forces imposed on the wire. Why 550oC? Because we know it works. The application of these principles will become more obvious when we review the metallurgy of brass in a few minutes.

In the meantime let’s look at this concept of heat of sublimation to see if we can make some sense of it. All matter exists as one of three phases: as a solid, as a liquid, or as a gas (vapor). You are no doubt familiar with the process which describes the transformation of a solid to a liquid, i.e. melting, or a liquid to a gas or vapor, i.e. boiling. However it is also possible to transform a solid directly to a gas or vapor, and that process is called sublimation. Although the terminology may not be familiar to you, the process may well be.

Consider for a moment two blocks of ice, one wet ice (frozen water ) and the other dry ice (solid carbon dioxide).  

Phase Changes of Ice

Phase Changes of Ice

Consider what will happen if we apply heat to the two blocks of ice. The wet ice will melt forming droplets of water. It turns out there will also be some water vapor in equilibrium with the liquid water as there will always be a gaseous phase in equilibrium with a liquid phase although the amount of gas may be minuscule. If we were then to withdraw the heat, and go so far as to freeze what remains, we would find smaller pieces of solid ice and a snowflake or two formed from the vapor phase.

In the case of the dry ice, the application of heat will cause the dry ice to vaporize without forming any liquid phase (hence the term dry ice). The block would slowly disappear as it sublimed. If one were to then refreeze that which now existed, one would have absolutely nothing since the carbon dioxide gas would have diffused away and could only be returned to a solid state if it were subjected to extreme pressure and cold.

Now let us take one step back toward the world of EDM by considering two solid blocks of “Metal M” and a “Metal V.”

Phase Changes of Metals.png

Let us say “Metal M” is similar to H2O and has a tendency to melt first and form very little vapor phase. Such a metal would be characterized as having a high heat of sublimation, i.e. it would take a lot of energy to transform it directly from a solid to a vapor. Let us further say “Metal V” is similar to dry ice (CO2) and has a tendency to vaporize very readily. Such a metal would be characterized as having a low heat of sublimation, i.e. it would take a relatively small amount of energy to transform it directly from a solid to a vapor.

Just as we did with the ice, suppose we were to now to withdraw heat form these examples and were to freeze, or in metallurgical parlance, to quench these systems. In the case of “Metal M,” we would get relatively large pieces of solid from the liquid and relatively small pieces of solid form the vapor in a manner similar to the way the wet ice behaved. In the case of “Metal V,” we would get the same relatively small pieces of solid as we got from the vapor phase of “Metal M,” but none of the larger pieces of solid that previously came from the liquid phase.

If you were wondering what the point of this discussion might be, consider the fact that the sequence we have just described is analogous to what goes on during the EDM process.

Phase Changes in Metals 2.png

The electrical discharge in the EDM process generates an intense heat locally and melts and/or vaporizes a small volume of both the wire and the workpiece. This all occurs in a plasma envelope which eventually collapses under the pressure of the dielectric fluid, thereby quenching the liquid/vapor phases that are present. The solid particulate thus formed is the debris in the gap which must be disposed of (flushed away) in order to maintain the electrical conditions necessary to reform additional discharges. Let me assure you it is much easier to flush the smaller particulate than it is to flush the larger particulate, as you can well imagine. In addition the larger particulate can form a conductive path to initiate a D.C. arc which we will see later can cause instantaneous wire breakage.

Returning full cycle to where we started, it is very helpful to have some knowledge of the relative heats of sublimation of the materials we must deal with in WEDM because that will give us an idea of their relative flush-abilities.

The next edition of WEDM Tech Wise we’ll provide just that sort of information. “May your Sparks always be ON-TIME!”

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

5 Myths of Wire Electric Discharge Machining (WEDM)

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

These 5 Myths of WEDM all fit Webster’s definition of a myth as they can all be shown to be fictitious.

Myth 1. Wires with a low “Vaporization Temperature” run cooler and therefore break less frequently!

Myth 2. HIGHER tensile strength wire will always solve a Wire breakage problem!

Myth 3. If it costs twice as much, it better cut twice as fast! 

Myth 4. FLUSHING FLUSHING & FLUSHING is all about dielectric water pressure!

Myth 5. This wire is best for All applications!


Myth 1. Wires with a low “Vaporization Temperature” run cooler and therefore break less frequently!

I would like to spend a few extra minutes discussing the first myth because it is an excellent example of how inaccurate information gets introduced into a technology, and when no one challenges it, it soon becomes an accepted part of the lore. This myth has inaccurate statement, stacked on top of inaccurate statement, but to this day it is repeated as the gospel in “authoritative” books. It can be traced back to the patent (U.S. Patent No. 4,287,404) that was issued for “A-Type” wires.

Therein lies part of the problem. You would think anything in an issued patent must have been reviewed by “experts” and therefore must be correct, right? Wrong! Inventors are not required to explain why their widget works better; they are only required to prove their widget works better. However, few can resist the temptation to explain why. Unfortunately, patent examiners rarely comment on these explanations, presumably because they have no need to.

This myth originated in the explanation as to why pure zinc works better on the surface of an EDM wire that was offered by the inventors of zinc coated wire. Let us examine it in detail. For starters, there is no such thing as “a vaporization temperature” of metals. Metals vaporize over a range of temperatures, although the amount vaporized at low temperatures may be minuscule. When you see someone list the “vaporization temperature” of metals, it most frequently represents a listing of their boiling points. A boiling point is defined as the temperature at which a liquid maintains a gaseous partial pressure of one atmosphere (760 torr) over its liquid phase. www.chem.purdue.edu/gchelp/liquids/boil.html - Referenced info from Purdue University.

 At fifty degrees below the boiling point, there will still be quite significant vapor pressure present. The fact that metals do not posses a vaporization temperature is the first error in this myth. The speculation that by vaporizing the zinc, the wire will run cooler is highly suspect and might be considered the second error. In theory, the statement would be true under most circumstances. Indeed evaporative cooling is a well-known phenomena and was the theory behind the ablative heat shields used on re-entry vehicles of early Space Missions. Unfortunately in EDM, the wire is not in the vacuum of space but is rather immersed in dielectric fluid which will most likely cool the surface far more effectively by conduction than by evaporation. However, let’s not call this an error and concede the wire will run cooler, even though that is highly unlikely. Now we come to a clear error. The inventors speculated that since the wire ran cooler, it would be less likely to fail by thermal shock. Sorry, metals do not fail from thermal shock; ceramics fail from thermal shock. As I mentioned, you will still see this myth repeated time and again as the gospel. Do not be taken in by such techno-babble. This is not to say high performance wires do not work. They work very well, thank you, and I hope in time we all will have a good understanding as to why.  

Myth 2. Higher tensile strength wire will always solve a wire breakage problem

     The second myth has to do with tensile strength. If you think science has been dealt a cruel blow using the term “vaporization temperature”, wait till you see what they have done to tensile strength. It is probably the most misunderstood and abused concept in the WEDM literature.

I have seen it hopelessly confused with load carrying capacity (they are not the same thing), and no, higher tensile strength wire will not cure wire breakage problems.

Does that mean tensile strength is not important? Absolutely not! It has very little to do with wire breakage, but it has a lot to do with most automatic wire threading systems.     

Kind of like SUPERMAN solves ALL the worlds problems – He Doesn’t, right?

Kind of like SUPERMAN solves ALL the worlds problems – He Doesn’t, right?

Myth 3. If it costs twice as much, it better cut twice as fast 

The third myth is not one of technology, but rather one of economics. No, if it costs twice as much, it does not need to cut twice as fast to be quite valuable.

Time savings is time saved and Time is of course money that can be made by making more parts. Every advantage needs to be taken wither it is twice as fast or 50% faster.

There is still value in time saved! 

The Speeds are for reference and are averages from our tests that we have performed on a Exectek Machine. These are high performance EDM wires that are available for purchase at our website online stores.

We feel confident that our wire offerings are the best in the industry and the speed can be increased as the .110” or 2.794mm per minute are not the highest speeds reached, they are averages that can be achieved in real life contour cuts. (Without Wire Breaks) Comparison of speed data without a clear definition of testing methodology and machine tool employed is a mistake. It is like judging a book by the cover!

Myth 4. FLUSHING, FLUSHING & FLUSHING is all about the Dielectric Water Pressure!

To me this is the one myth that really needs to be addressed.

Simply stated flushing is not all about high pressure water pumps and the machines artificial intelligence.  (The Spark Gap monitoring) 

The choice of wire types which offers a variety of wire constructions has a huge impact on flushing and therefore wire breaks. Because the wire coating proprieties will make smaller erosion debris, which is just as or more important than the water pressure. Stay tuned for a more complete discussion of wire constructions in follow-up editions of the WEDM Tech Wize.

Remember: WEDM is NOT Abrasive Water Jet Cutting!

 Myth 5. This wire is best for All applications!

Finally there is the need to understand where specific wire types can be used most effectively.

There is no “ideal” EDM wire type that can be all things to all applications. However by understanding the construction of wire types, one is better positioned to make intelligent choices. That is what we plan to accomplish with todays GIP High Performance EDM Wire. 

Let’s start by considering the metallurgical properties we need to concentrate on in the NEXT edition of WEDM Tech Wize.  “May your Sparks always be ON-TIME!”

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize

https://www.gip-edmwire.com/wedm-tech-wize